Saturday, May 13, 2017
Book review: First Impressions by Sarah Price
The twenty-fifth book I read in 2017 was First Impressions: An Amish Tale of Pride and Prejudice by Sarah Price, and it's exactly as awful as you'd expect the unholy union of Austen fan-fic and Amish romances to be. I have nothing to blame but my own morbid curiosity.
Friday, May 12, 2017
Spelling vanquished!
About six years ago, Faith started her spelling book. There were three words to learn and one sentence to write: "See the moon."
Looking ahead to the end of the book from such humble beginnings, I quailed. How would we two ever get to the point where she could write the last dictation in the book, including punctuation?
Well, as of today, she has finished her spelling book, including that meandering, clause-ridden, eight-line question from The Spectator, archaic "ere" and all. It is a 1908 speller, handed down from a schoolteaching great-aunt, and from it the kids have written excerpts from Dickens and T. H. Huxley, letters to their children by Victor Hugo and William Makepeace Thackeray, poetry by Wordsworth and Longfellow, lists of "Largest Cities in United States" that are now mostly Rust Belt ghost towns and of American authors who are largely forgotten today, and many words that are uncommon now but if they run across them in old books, they'll know them. (Did you know what a quire is? We do now. Win at Scrabble!)
Looking ahead to the end of the book from such humble beginnings, I quailed. How would we two ever get to the point where she could write the last dictation in the book, including punctuation?
Well, as of today, she has finished her spelling book, including that meandering, clause-ridden, eight-line question from The Spectator, archaic "ere" and all. It is a 1908 speller, handed down from a schoolteaching great-aunt, and from it the kids have written excerpts from Dickens and T. H. Huxley, letters to their children by Victor Hugo and William Makepeace Thackeray, poetry by Wordsworth and Longfellow, lists of "Largest Cities in United States" that are now mostly Rust Belt ghost towns and of American authors who are largely forgotten today, and many words that are uncommon now but if they run across them in old books, they'll know them. (Did you know what a quire is? We do now. Win at Scrabble!)
Sunday, May 7, 2017
Book review: "When You Were Gentiles" by Cavan W. Concannon
The twenty-fourth book I read in 2017 was "When You Were Gentiles": Specters of Ethnicity in Roman Corinth and Paul's Corinthian Correspondence by Cavan W. Concannon. This book began as a dissertation, and it reads like it. The academic prose is heavy and repetitive, with extra padding: first Concannon tells you what he's going to tell you, then he tells you, then he tells you what he just told you.
The jargon might be worth hacking one's way through if there were anything interesting on offer beneath the verbiage, but all this sound and fury, at base, comes down to speculation. The recipients of the epistles may have been this or that; they may have practiced some or another occupation; they may have had picnics in graveyards. There's no facts at bottom, no documentation, only some snapshots from the author's vacation in Greece. The one thing Concannon seems to be sure of, based on his repeated pledges of allegiance to feminist and postcolonial scholarship, is that the Corinthians definitely disagreed with Paul and that the apostle'swhite (oops) male interference in their community was unwelcome and officious.
The jargon might be worth hacking one's way through if there were anything interesting on offer beneath the verbiage, but all this sound and fury, at base, comes down to speculation. The recipients of the epistles may have been this or that; they may have practiced some or another occupation; they may have had picnics in graveyards. There's no facts at bottom, no documentation, only some snapshots from the author's vacation in Greece. The one thing Concannon seems to be sure of, based on his repeated pledges of allegiance to feminist and postcolonial scholarship, is that the Corinthians definitely disagreed with Paul and that the apostle's
Saturday, May 6, 2017
Friday, April 21, 2017
Story connoisseurs
So I was reading this interview with a children's author. I have read nothing he has written and can't give an opinion on the quality of his work, but his response to a question interested me.
Haven't you ever had the experience of watching a movie or reading a book you loved as a child and finding it wasn't as good as you remembered it being? Or watching an old black-and-white movie that won multiple awards and being underwhelmed, finding it treacly and obvious? I know that The Pickwick Papers was considered so uproariously hilarious that it launched Charles Dickens' writing career, but I have tried to read that book and found it completely leaden.
Now, granted, what cultures find funny changes over time and the studio politics and the power of personality have rendered Oscar choices inexplicable on occasion. But perhaps it's simply a measure of our culture, or we individually, simply becoming more sophisticated evaluators of story over time. Perhaps it's not just that Hollywood is turning out more dreck than usual these days; perhaps Hollywood has always churned out bucketsful of dreck, but we're now more choosy though exposure to decades of films. Excellent story, whether in book or movie form, is always going to be in the minority compared to the mediocre or worse.
Is good storytelling a lost art today?
I would say the opposite. We in America today are some of the most sophisticated story consumers history has ever seen. Most adults are so exposed to narrative that they’re almost a little inoculated to it. It’s very hard to impress them.
Haven't you ever had the experience of watching a movie or reading a book you loved as a child and finding it wasn't as good as you remembered it being? Or watching an old black-and-white movie that won multiple awards and being underwhelmed, finding it treacly and obvious? I know that The Pickwick Papers was considered so uproariously hilarious that it launched Charles Dickens' writing career, but I have tried to read that book and found it completely leaden.
Now, granted, what cultures find funny changes over time and the studio politics and the power of personality have rendered Oscar choices inexplicable on occasion. But perhaps it's simply a measure of our culture, or we individually, simply becoming more sophisticated evaluators of story over time. Perhaps it's not just that Hollywood is turning out more dreck than usual these days; perhaps Hollywood has always churned out bucketsful of dreck, but we're now more choosy though exposure to decades of films. Excellent story, whether in book or movie form, is always going to be in the minority compared to the mediocre or worse.
Thursday, April 20, 2017
Book review: Prisoners of Geography by Tim Marshall
The twenty-third book I read in 2017 was Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps That Explain Everything About the World by Tim Marshall. This book was on my wishlist for quite a while before I read it, and I ended up being disappointed by it.
Obviously the subtitle is an overstatement, but that's not the source of my disappointment; rather, I was expecting a historical view of how different cultures were shaped by their geography, whereas Marshall's book is much more focused on current events. It's not his fault that he didn't write the book I wanted to read, but it will definitely date the book. For instance, the chapter on Western Europe discusses the stresses that the Greek economy has put on the European Union and the possibility that it may lead some Southern European countries to break with the EU -- but there's nary a word about Brexit, which clearly took Marshall by surprise as much as it did the rest of the world. (Of course, Britain's geography could help explain why it feels separate from the Continent, but Marshall doesn't address the possibility.)
Also, Marshall bemoans the artificial boundaries imposed in Africa and the Middle East by colonial powers as a major cause of civil war. Isn't the alternative -- if tribes had been allowed to define for themselves who was in and who was out and where the demarcations were between their territories and their neighbors -- simply ordinary war? Is crossing national boundaries to seize resources by force somehow less morally reprehensible than taking them from your fellow countrymen? I'll concede that not having to cooperate with people you judge to be outsiders might eliminate some conflict, but a neighboring tribe having diamonds or minerals or oil or access to an ocean port in their territory will still tempt invasion; witness the first Gulf War.
I did learn some things: for instance, that Bangladesh used to be East Pakistan and that its economic development is hampered by the fact that most of its country lies in a flood plain and suffers from seasonal inundations. That DAESH is an insulting way to refer to the terrorists of the Islamic State, as it rhymes with several unsavory Arabic words. That trade and peaceful coexistence of people groups thrived in Europe because of its easily navigable rivers, while the dangerous rivers of Africa and South America kept peoples isolated from each other and retarded the growth of civilization.
Marshall concludes the book, in an optimistic tone that would have fit the 1960s better than the 2010s, by looking forward to what he considers the inevitable expansion of humanity to other planets. He wonders if the nations of Earth will continue their competitive and acquisitive ways, rushing to plant their individual flags on other planets like Columbus on San Salvador, or whether moving past a global perspective will encourage humanity to band together as a species, as Virginians and Pennsylvanians became Americans in the latter 18th century. I am cynical enough both to doubt that science (and our current panic to make sure everything is "safe") will overcome the technological hazards of interplanetary travel and colonization of planets nonconducive to human life and to wager that the only way we will overcome our differences will be if we encounter a larger enemy. But that's a sci-fi film.
Obviously the subtitle is an overstatement, but that's not the source of my disappointment; rather, I was expecting a historical view of how different cultures were shaped by their geography, whereas Marshall's book is much more focused on current events. It's not his fault that he didn't write the book I wanted to read, but it will definitely date the book. For instance, the chapter on Western Europe discusses the stresses that the Greek economy has put on the European Union and the possibility that it may lead some Southern European countries to break with the EU -- but there's nary a word about Brexit, which clearly took Marshall by surprise as much as it did the rest of the world. (Of course, Britain's geography could help explain why it feels separate from the Continent, but Marshall doesn't address the possibility.)
Also, Marshall bemoans the artificial boundaries imposed in Africa and the Middle East by colonial powers as a major cause of civil war. Isn't the alternative -- if tribes had been allowed to define for themselves who was in and who was out and where the demarcations were between their territories and their neighbors -- simply ordinary war? Is crossing national boundaries to seize resources by force somehow less morally reprehensible than taking them from your fellow countrymen? I'll concede that not having to cooperate with people you judge to be outsiders might eliminate some conflict, but a neighboring tribe having diamonds or minerals or oil or access to an ocean port in their territory will still tempt invasion; witness the first Gulf War.
I did learn some things: for instance, that Bangladesh used to be East Pakistan and that its economic development is hampered by the fact that most of its country lies in a flood plain and suffers from seasonal inundations. That DAESH is an insulting way to refer to the terrorists of the Islamic State, as it rhymes with several unsavory Arabic words. That trade and peaceful coexistence of people groups thrived in Europe because of its easily navigable rivers, while the dangerous rivers of Africa and South America kept peoples isolated from each other and retarded the growth of civilization.
Marshall concludes the book, in an optimistic tone that would have fit the 1960s better than the 2010s, by looking forward to what he considers the inevitable expansion of humanity to other planets. He wonders if the nations of Earth will continue their competitive and acquisitive ways, rushing to plant their individual flags on other planets like Columbus on San Salvador, or whether moving past a global perspective will encourage humanity to band together as a species, as Virginians and Pennsylvanians became Americans in the latter 18th century. I am cynical enough both to doubt that science (and our current panic to make sure everything is "safe") will overcome the technological hazards of interplanetary travel and colonization of planets nonconducive to human life and to wager that the only way we will overcome our differences will be if we encounter a larger enemy. But that's a sci-fi film.
Sunday, April 9, 2017
Book review: Daddy-Long-Legs and Dear Enemy by Jean Webster
The Mother-Daughter Book Club series induced me to seek out Jean Webster's Daddy-Long-Legs, as it is the featured title in book three of the series, Dear Pen Pal. Thus, it and its sequel, Dear Enemy, became the twenty-second book I read in 2017. (Even though they are separate works, the edition I read was a two-in-one.)
Daddy-Long-Legs is an epistolary novel made up of letters written by seventeen-year-old orphan Jerusha Abbott to the anonymous benefactor who finances her college education. She knows only that he is a trustee of the orphan asylum where she has spend her childhood and caught but a glimpse of a tall man walking out the door. Based on that impression and the condition that she send him monthly letters reporting on her progress, she begins writing to him as Daddy-Long-Legs.
For much of the book, I was wholly delighted, wondering how on earth I had managed to miss this book while reading extensively in the plucky-orphaned-girl genre (i.e., Anne of Green Gables, Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm, Pollyanna, etc.). Eventually, however, I understood how this book had been excluded from my childhood: its extolment of Darwinian evolution and fervent socialism in particular.
In addition -- spoiler alert --
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
In addition, there's something creepy and off-putting today about a grown man anonymously grooming a teenage girl to be his bride, and the later triangle of Judy, Jervie, and Jimmie McBride is unfair in many ways.
Dear Enemy is Daddy-Long-Legs's sequel. The letters in this instance are written from Judy's friend Sallie McBride to Judy (and others) after Judy has persuaded her to take over the orphan asylum where Judy was brought up, the John Grier Home, and run it in a more humane and progressive manner than Judy enjoyed. It is not as successful as Daddy-Long-Legs but still a good read.
Daddy-Long-Legs is an epistolary novel made up of letters written by seventeen-year-old orphan Jerusha Abbott to the anonymous benefactor who finances her college education. She knows only that he is a trustee of the orphan asylum where she has spend her childhood and caught but a glimpse of a tall man walking out the door. Based on that impression and the condition that she send him monthly letters reporting on her progress, she begins writing to him as Daddy-Long-Legs.
For much of the book, I was wholly delighted, wondering how on earth I had managed to miss this book while reading extensively in the plucky-orphaned-girl genre (i.e., Anne of Green Gables, Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm, Pollyanna, etc.). Eventually, however, I understood how this book had been excluded from my childhood: its extolment of Darwinian evolution and fervent socialism in particular.
In addition -- spoiler alert --
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
In addition, there's something creepy and off-putting today about a grown man anonymously grooming a teenage girl to be his bride, and the later triangle of Judy, Jervie, and Jimmie McBride is unfair in many ways.
Dear Enemy is Daddy-Long-Legs's sequel. The letters in this instance are written from Judy's friend Sallie McBride to Judy (and others) after Judy has persuaded her to take over the orphan asylum where Judy was brought up, the John Grier Home, and run it in a more humane and progressive manner than Judy enjoyed. It is not as successful as Daddy-Long-Legs but still a good read.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Blog Archive
Labels
- Agatha Christie (3)
- Alexander McCall Smith (23)
- apologia pro sua vita (49)
- Art Linkletter (29)
- Austeniana (10)
- bibliography (248)
- birthday (21)
- Charles Lenox (3)
- Christmas (29)
- deep thoughts by Jack Handy (16)
- Grantchester Mysteries (4)
- Halloween (10)
- high horse (55)
- Holly Homemaker (19)
- Hornblower (3)
- Inspector Alan Grant (6)
- Isabel Dalhousie (8)
- life-changing magic! (5)
- Lord Peter Wimsey (6)
- Maisie Dobbs (9)
- Mark Forsyth (2)
- Mother-Daughter Book Club (9)
- No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency (14)
- photo opportunity (103)
- pop goes the culture (73)
- rampant silliness (17)
- refrigerator door (11)
- Rosemary Sutcliff (9)
- something borrowed (73)
- the grandeur that was (11)
- where the time goes (70)



