Today's Wall Street Journal features an opinion piece entitled "What Jane Austen Can Teach Us About Sexual Harassment." Far be it from me ever to disapprove of Elizabeth Bennet as a role model, but it takes some mental gymnastics to see Mr. Collins as a sexual harasser. The man proposed marriage to a woman out of his league and was turned down; he didn't invite Lizzy to his hotel room while he was in the shower, or drug her, or ask to show her his little friend, or threaten that she'll never be proposed to in this town again. Elizabeth finds him ridiculous, not intimidating; she has no fear of him.
I think that when we've reached a point that asking out a woman who isn't interested in you counts as sexual impropriety, we have painted all men with a broad brush. How are they to know if a woman would like to go out with them if they aren't allowed to ask? I've turned down dates with men who have asked me out in my day without deeming them moral monsters for asking. I mean, sure, if they won't take no for an answer and start stalking you, like Richard Nixon did to Pat, that's creepy and may call for a restraining order, but considering that Mr. Collins moved on to Charlotte Lucas the same day, one cannot fault his behavior (in this respect, anyway). Is it not enough that Mr. Collins is held up for posterity as a buffoon without also stigmatizing him as a cad?
Tuesday, January 2, 2018
Monday, January 1, 2018
You say you want a resolution
I think it's time for another resolution of weekdaily blogging for 2018. My kids are older and less prone to adorable malapropisms, but I have my book reviews if I can keep up with them. Watch this space!
Thursday, December 28, 2017
Book review: Lord Hornblower by C. S. Forester
The seventy-sixth book I read in 2017 is the penultimate entry (chronologically) in C. S. Forester's Hornblower series, Lord Hornblower.
Commodore Hornblower, having recovered from the typhus which sent him back to England to convalesce at the end of the last book, is charged with the tricky task of recovering a ship that has mutinied off the coast of France. Having accomplished his goal, he is presented with the opportunity to foment a rebellion against Napoleon in northern France, which leads to an extended sequence off the water in which Hornblower takes up politics. As telegraphed by the title, Hornblower is elevated to the peerage for his efforts, but this leads to a rift in his relationship with Lady Barbara.
This book, more than any other, focuses on the women in Hornblower's life, from poor dead Maria to Marie to Lady Barbara, none of whom he does right by. I give Forester points for hinting at Hornblower's basic selfishness in his relationships with them, but one can't help but feel that all three are important only to the extent they further Hornblower's story: They are ripe for the fridging. Worse, ...
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
A
L
E
R
T
... Forester kills off Bush in this installment. Granted, it's off-screen, and there's no body found; Forester had some experience as a Hollywood screenwriter, and if there's one thing you can count on in a movie, it's that if you don't see a body, they're not really dead. I hold out some hope for poor loyal Bush, but it seems more likely that his is yet another corpse stuffed in the fridge for Hornblower's inner monologue to pontificate over.
Still, despite my distaste for parts of the book, the overall story line is compelling, and Hornblower is left at the end of the narrative in an unresolved Lady-or-the-Tiger situation. It is an open and explicit question what will ensue when he meets Lady Barbara again, made the more intriguing by the fact that, when it was actually published, it would be twelve years before the author returned to answer the question, as he went back and filled in his character's backstory before writing forward in the chronology again.
Commodore Hornblower, having recovered from the typhus which sent him back to England to convalesce at the end of the last book, is charged with the tricky task of recovering a ship that has mutinied off the coast of France. Having accomplished his goal, he is presented with the opportunity to foment a rebellion against Napoleon in northern France, which leads to an extended sequence off the water in which Hornblower takes up politics. As telegraphed by the title, Hornblower is elevated to the peerage for his efforts, but this leads to a rift in his relationship with Lady Barbara.
This book, more than any other, focuses on the women in Hornblower's life, from poor dead Maria to Marie to Lady Barbara, none of whom he does right by. I give Forester points for hinting at Hornblower's basic selfishness in his relationships with them, but one can't help but feel that all three are important only to the extent they further Hornblower's story: They are ripe for the fridging. Worse, ...
S
P
O
I
L
E
R
A
L
E
R
T
... Forester kills off Bush in this installment. Granted, it's off-screen, and there's no body found; Forester had some experience as a Hollywood screenwriter, and if there's one thing you can count on in a movie, it's that if you don't see a body, they're not really dead. I hold out some hope for poor loyal Bush, but it seems more likely that his is yet another corpse stuffed in the fridge for Hornblower's inner monologue to pontificate over.
Still, despite my distaste for parts of the book, the overall story line is compelling, and Hornblower is left at the end of the narrative in an unresolved Lady-or-the-Tiger situation. It is an open and explicit question what will ensue when he meets Lady Barbara again, made the more intriguing by the fact that, when it was actually published, it would be twelve years before the author returned to answer the question, as he went back and filled in his character's backstory before writing forward in the chronology again.
Wednesday, December 13, 2017
Book review: Dear Pen Pal by Heather Vogel Frederick
The seventy-fourth book I read in 2017 was the third installment in Heather Vogel Frederick's The Mother-Daughter Book Club series, Dear Pen Pal. This year, the girls and moms are reading Daddy-Long-Legs, so Emma's mom contacts her college roommate in Wyoming who is naturally enough running a five-member mother-daughter book club of her own and pairs each girl up with a pen pal for the year.
Another parallel with the classic is that Jess is contacted out of the blue by a private girls' boarding school she never applied to and told she has been awarded a scholarship for eighth grade. Jess and her family are notified of this award on Labor Day weekend. Despite that fact that the school is in her home town, she moves into the dormitory and has to live with a stuck-up roommate who is the daughter of a U.S. senator. Sweet Valley, I'm telling you.
Megan's grandmother from China moves to America to live with her family; Cassidy's mother has a baby with her new husband; Jess's mysterious benefactor is finally revealed; and the whole troup flies out to Wyoming to meet their pen pals at the end of the year.
Megan's grandmother Gigi is an interesting new character, but the best thing about this book was that it motivated me to read Daddy-Long-Legs.
Another parallel with the classic is that Jess is contacted out of the blue by a private girls' boarding school she never applied to and told she has been awarded a scholarship for eighth grade. Jess and her family are notified of this award on Labor Day weekend. Despite that fact that the school is in her home town, she moves into the dormitory and has to live with a stuck-up roommate who is the daughter of a U.S. senator. Sweet Valley, I'm telling you.
Megan's grandmother from China moves to America to live with her family; Cassidy's mother has a baby with her new husband; Jess's mysterious benefactor is finally revealed; and the whole troup flies out to Wyoming to meet their pen pals at the end of the year.
Megan's grandmother Gigi is an interesting new character, but the best thing about this book was that it motivated me to read Daddy-Long-Legs.
Saturday, December 9, 2017
Saturday, October 21, 2017
Book review: Knight's Fee by Rosemary Sutcliff
The sixty-third book I read in 2017 was Knight's Fee by Rosemary Sutcliff. Another historical novel set in Britain, it is not explicitly part of the Eagle of the Ninth series, as the green dolphin ring makes no appearance. Set around the turn of the twelfth century, it deals with an orphaned dog-boy whose life changes dramatically when a new lord arrives to take over the manor. Having drawn the ire of the new lord, Randal is saved by the intervention of a minstrel, who plays a game of chess for his life.
Raised alongside the grandson of another lord, Randal serves as varlet and then squire, attaining a life far beyond any he could have hoped for as a child-drudge, but he believes that knighthood will remain forever beyond his reach, as he has no wealth or possessions that will enable him to pay his knight's fee to any lord. Think of Arthur and Kay in T.H. White's The Sword in the Stone, if Kay were an actual likeable character and not an unbearable snob. The bromance between Randal and Bevis is perhaps the most affecting since Marcus and Esca's in Sutcliff's most famous work, albeit experienced from the lower-status side this time around.
This book would make a good companion to a module on feudalism and knighthood in the Middle Ages, but it is also an enjoyable read on its own.
Raised alongside the grandson of another lord, Randal serves as varlet and then squire, attaining a life far beyond any he could have hoped for as a child-drudge, but he believes that knighthood will remain forever beyond his reach, as he has no wealth or possessions that will enable him to pay his knight's fee to any lord. Think of Arthur and Kay in T.H. White's The Sword in the Stone, if Kay were an actual likeable character and not an unbearable snob. The bromance between Randal and Bevis is perhaps the most affecting since Marcus and Esca's in Sutcliff's most famous work, albeit experienced from the lower-status side this time around.
This book would make a good companion to a module on feudalism and knighthood in the Middle Ages, but it is also an enjoyable read on its own.
Thursday, October 12, 2017
Book review: Sidney Chambers and the Forgiveness of Sins by James Runcie
The sixtieth book I read in 2017 was the fourth book in The Grantchester Mysteries by James Runcie, Sidney Chambers and the Forgiveness of Sins. My reviews of the previous books in the series have not been stellar, but I am nothing if not a completist; and perhaps I'm getting soft, but I found this installment less objectionable than some of its predecessors. This is undoubtedly in part due to the demise of the low-chemistry love triangle that dominated the first books before Sidney's marriage to Hildegard.
As with the previous installments in the series, the book is made up of separate stories. The first one, which provides the title of the book as a whole, begins with a sort of locked-room mystery which seems far too cool and intriguing for this series and, sadly, is. The denouement represents the least interesting solution possible to the situation as presented.
The second story, "Nothing to Worry About," is more typical of the series, in that a situation which is being gossiped about turns out boringly to be exactly what everyone already assumed it was. "Fugue" is probably the most interesting story in the book, as well as being the bloodiest and most opaque. As of "A Following," these are no longer technically Grantchester mysteries, as Sidney has left his position as vicar of that church and accepted a position as archdeacon at Ely. (I have no idea where these places are, other than somewhere around Cambridge, nor how far apart they may be. Inspector Keating mentions they will need to find a new pub at which to meet.) Sidney's annoying pseudo-ex Amanda receives threatening letters and phone calls from her latest fiance's actual ex. "Prize Day" delves into the cliche of homosexuality and abuse in England's school system, and in "Florence," Sidney travels to Italy and is accused of art theft.
As always, the biggest problem with these books is that Runcie is not a novelist but a television writer, and it shows desperately. Page after page of dialogue with nary a "he said" nor a "she shifted uneasily in her chair as she replied." Runcie is used to actors supplying the tones of voice and body language which reveals character; in their absence, it's like listening to a bored blind table-read. This paragraph introduces a new character:
"Sir Mark Kirby-Grey had the air of a preoccupied man who was doing his best and was not prepared to take criticism. Prematurely bald, and smaller than he wanted to be, he wore a bespoke navy suit with one cuff button undone, and he spoke to everyone as if they were employees who fell short. Unused to relaxation or sitting still, he preferred to 'get on with things', and his quick attentive movements were either a sign of shyness and social discomfort or a deliberate attempt to remind people of his influence and importance."
That's not a paragraph in a novel; it's an actor's brief on how to play a character. A competent novelist will show you these traits through a character's speech and actions over the course of a scene, not drop them all in an explanatory paragraph when the character enters stage-left. Show; don't tell.
Other complaints: Runcie seems determined that his readers view Amanda as Sidney's ultimate soulmate and 'the one that got away,' despite the fact that the character is thoroughly unlikable and the pairing has never emitted more sparks than a pile of wet newspaper.
Sidney's new curate, a thoroughly two-dimensional character whose actor's brief seems to consist solely of the phrase "likes cake," preaches a sermon which explicitly contradicts the words of Christ and condemns Jesus as "overgenerous," with neither fictional congregation nor living author seems to realize as a heretical statement from the pulpit. (In the meantime, Sidney rebukes another character for taking the Lord's name in vain, because priorities, I guess.)
In questions of fact and verisimilitude, Sidney, in 1964, considers a sermon in which he would "quote from one of the last lines of that great Christmas film It's a Wonderful Life." It's a Wonderful Life would hardly be considered a Christmas classic in 1964, as it bombed at the box office on release and didn't gain an audience until its copyright lapsed in 1974 and it began to be shown in abundance on American TV at Christmastime in the 1980s because it was a cheap way to fill holiday airwaves. I knew a British girl in college in the early '90s who had never heard of the film.
And for the sake of all that's holy, if you're going to do a mad-wife-hidden-in-the-attic story, don't draw attention to the hoary old chestnut by having a character ostentatiously read Jane Eyre earlier in the book.
As with the previous installments in the series, the book is made up of separate stories. The first one, which provides the title of the book as a whole, begins with a sort of locked-room mystery which seems far too cool and intriguing for this series and, sadly, is. The denouement represents the least interesting solution possible to the situation as presented.
The second story, "Nothing to Worry About," is more typical of the series, in that a situation which is being gossiped about turns out boringly to be exactly what everyone already assumed it was. "Fugue" is probably the most interesting story in the book, as well as being the bloodiest and most opaque. As of "A Following," these are no longer technically Grantchester mysteries, as Sidney has left his position as vicar of that church and accepted a position as archdeacon at Ely. (I have no idea where these places are, other than somewhere around Cambridge, nor how far apart they may be. Inspector Keating mentions they will need to find a new pub at which to meet.) Sidney's annoying pseudo-ex Amanda receives threatening letters and phone calls from her latest fiance's actual ex. "Prize Day" delves into the cliche of homosexuality and abuse in England's school system, and in "Florence," Sidney travels to Italy and is accused of art theft.
As always, the biggest problem with these books is that Runcie is not a novelist but a television writer, and it shows desperately. Page after page of dialogue with nary a "he said" nor a "she shifted uneasily in her chair as she replied." Runcie is used to actors supplying the tones of voice and body language which reveals character; in their absence, it's like listening to a bored blind table-read. This paragraph introduces a new character:
"Sir Mark Kirby-Grey had the air of a preoccupied man who was doing his best and was not prepared to take criticism. Prematurely bald, and smaller than he wanted to be, he wore a bespoke navy suit with one cuff button undone, and he spoke to everyone as if they were employees who fell short. Unused to relaxation or sitting still, he preferred to 'get on with things', and his quick attentive movements were either a sign of shyness and social discomfort or a deliberate attempt to remind people of his influence and importance."
That's not a paragraph in a novel; it's an actor's brief on how to play a character. A competent novelist will show you these traits through a character's speech and actions over the course of a scene, not drop them all in an explanatory paragraph when the character enters stage-left. Show; don't tell.
Other complaints: Runcie seems determined that his readers view Amanda as Sidney's ultimate soulmate and 'the one that got away,' despite the fact that the character is thoroughly unlikable and the pairing has never emitted more sparks than a pile of wet newspaper.
Sidney's new curate, a thoroughly two-dimensional character whose actor's brief seems to consist solely of the phrase "likes cake," preaches a sermon which explicitly contradicts the words of Christ and condemns Jesus as "overgenerous," with neither fictional congregation nor living author seems to realize as a heretical statement from the pulpit. (In the meantime, Sidney rebukes another character for taking the Lord's name in vain, because priorities, I guess.)
In questions of fact and verisimilitude, Sidney, in 1964, considers a sermon in which he would "quote from one of the last lines of that great Christmas film It's a Wonderful Life." It's a Wonderful Life would hardly be considered a Christmas classic in 1964, as it bombed at the box office on release and didn't gain an audience until its copyright lapsed in 1974 and it began to be shown in abundance on American TV at Christmastime in the 1980s because it was a cheap way to fill holiday airwaves. I knew a British girl in college in the early '90s who had never heard of the film.
And for the sake of all that's holy, if you're going to do a mad-wife-hidden-in-the-attic story, don't draw attention to the hoary old chestnut by having a character ostentatiously read Jane Eyre earlier in the book.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Blog Archive
Labels
- Agatha Christie (3)
- Alexander McCall Smith (23)
- apologia pro sua vita (49)
- Art Linkletter (29)
- Austeniana (10)
- bibliography (248)
- birthday (21)
- Charles Lenox (3)
- Christmas (29)
- deep thoughts by Jack Handy (16)
- Grantchester Mysteries (4)
- Halloween (10)
- high horse (55)
- Holly Homemaker (19)
- Hornblower (3)
- Inspector Alan Grant (6)
- Isabel Dalhousie (8)
- life-changing magic! (5)
- Lord Peter Wimsey (6)
- Maisie Dobbs (9)
- Mark Forsyth (2)
- Mother-Daughter Book Club (9)
- No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency (14)
- photo opportunity (103)
- pop goes the culture (73)
- rampant silliness (17)
- refrigerator door (11)
- Rosemary Sutcliff (9)
- something borrowed (73)
- the grandeur that was (11)
- where the time goes (70)



