The thirty-fourth book I read in 2018 was another two-in-one: Betsy and the Great World and Betsy's Wedding by Maud Hart Lovelace. These are the ninth and tenth, and the final, books in the Betsy series.
Unlike the Harry-at-Hogwarts pacing of the previous four books, each of which covered a school year, Great World opens two and a half years after Betsy's high school graduation. What we learn of the intervening time in quick summary does not cover her with glory: Just like in high school, she goofed off in college, majoring in the social scene, and not only dropped out but started dating someone else after Joe transferred to Harvard and broke up with him again, after the interminable will-they-or-won't-they of their high school career.
Because Betsy must always land on her feet, however, her father has arranged for her to spend a year traveling in Europe. This book is much less a story and more a travelogue, based as it is on Lovelace's letters home from a similar trip of her own. As it stands, some of the text is cringeworthy, like Betsy's distaste for the Muslim neighborhoods she visits and her horrified sympathy for little girls wearing veils.
World War I breaks out before Betsy's grand tour is over, however, and it becomes the only truly successful part of the book, casting a bittersweet pall over the futures of all the European friends Betsy has made and (natch) prompting Betsy to make apologetic overtures to Joe. Unfortunately, the swoonworthy item in the Personals section of the London Times that brings her home -- "Betsy. The Great War is on but I hope ours is over. Please come home. Joe." -- is an anachronism. World War I didn't begin to be called the Great War until October 1917 so Joe was quite prescient to have termed it such in August 1914.
Wedding leaves the troubles in Europe behind for most of its length, being interested rather in Betsy and Joe's brief engagement, wedding, and setting up housekeeping. Unfortunately, it also leaves unaddressed many dangling plot threads from the previous books. The fates of Betsy's European acquaintances? Silence. There's no indication that Betsy even attempted to correspond with the friends she made in Great World. More annoying is Carney suddenly turning up married to a fellow named Sam in Minneapolis, after going off to Vassar with a place in her heart still reserved for Larry Humphreys. Whatever happened with that?
One part of Wedding that definitely works is when Joe's Aunt Ruth asks to come and live with the newlyweds. Having been widowed and sold the store she and her husband ran, she is lonely and wants a place to stay for a while. Joe, having been taken in by her as a child, cannot refuse, but Betsy's inner rebellion at the idea of sharing her love-nest with an outsider is entirely believable and well-portrayed. Her grudge poisons the happiness of the young marriage until she is able to let go of her resentment, and her submission is well-rewarded in many ways. Later, when Aunt Ruth decides to move to California to be near other relations, it's a real wrench, both to Betsy and to the reader, for her to leave.
While the Betsy books are based on Maud Hart Lovelace's real life, one strand of fiction running through them is Joe. In actuality, Maud didn't meet the man she would marry until 1917. She wanted to depict his story too in the series, but I can't help but feel that, in writing Joe in Betsy's life so early rather than giving his childhood a separate book as Laura Ingalls Wilder did with Farmer Boy, she did some violence to their story. Betsy and Joe are delightful in Wedding, but the will-they-won't-they through the previous five books turn them into a proto-Ross-and-Rachel. It's hard to feel that they will be good for each other when she gives them such an extended backstory of misunderstanding, callousness, and over-sensitivity.
An aside: These two-fer editions boast introductions by female authors and back matter delineating the real-life basis for the story. The back matter is excellent, but I have a bone to pick with the introductions. Heaven to Betsy and Betsy in Spite of Herself had an introduction by Laura Lippman, a name that was vaguely familiar to me though I have no idea what she has written; Betsy Was a Junior and Betsy and Joe was introduced by Meg Cabot who spent her pages advertising for her Princess Diary series and admitting that while it was sweet for Betsy to say that she didn't want any boy but the right one to kiss her, logically there was no way for Betsy to know who the right boy is unless she went around snogging all of them on offer (and you can see where that slippery slope is headed).
Betsy and the Great World and Betsy and Joe, however, has an introduction by Anna Quindlen, which I must call out for intellectual dishonesty. Quindlen's thesis is that Betsy is a feminist series, ahead of its time, and that without Lovelace's series, she would never have known that being an author was an option for women. In the first place, she herself lists Jane Austen as one of her favorite authors, a woman who was a successful author long before Lovelace's time. Beyond Austen are the Bronte sisters and Agatha Christie and Josephine Tey and Emily Dickinson and Harriet Beecher Stowe and Laura Ingalls Wilder and dozens of other very well-known female writers.
Her complaint, however, seems to be that these other authors didn't write books about fictional girls who wanted to be writers. Well, except for Louisa May Alcott and L. M. Montgomery, whom Quindlen discounts because Jo was "punished" for her ambition by not marrying Laurie and Anne "had" to support herself and thus didn't make a choice to pursue a writing career but was forced into in be necessity. This doesn't really scan with my impression of the Anne series, and I wonder if Quindlen realizes that Alcott wanted Jo to end Little Women a single woman with a successful career and was forced by her publisher to marry her off -- or the implied insult to Alcott that her failure to marry is something to be mourned.
Not to mention that Wedding would be denounced as retrograde rather than feminist today, with Betsy's insisting that she must learn to cook and keep house for Joe instead of accepting the public relations job she is offered in the course of the book.
Monday, August 20, 2018
Tuesday, August 7, 2018
Book review: Home for the Holidays by Heather Vogel Frederick
The thirty-third book I read in 2018 was the fifth book in Heather Vogel Frederick's Mother-Daughter Book Club series, Home for the Holidays. This time around, the girls tackle the Betsy-Tacy series, though they talk their moms down from the entire ten-book series to only Betsy's high school years: Heaven to Betsy, Betsy in Spite of Herself, Betsy Was a Junior, and Betsy and Joe.
This installment in the series is notable in that it marks the first time Becca, Chadwickius frenemus, gets to narrate point-of-view chapters. It's also different in that it encompasses only half a school year -- and most of that is in a quick flashback; the actual narrative covers only Thanksgiving through New Year's, that is, the "holidays" of the title.
Speaking of the title, no one actually is "home" over the school holidays. The Chadwicks and the Wongs have booked a cruise together, a plan that gets fraught with complications when Becca's dad loses his job; Jess and Emma spend Christmas with Jess's aunt and uncle in New Hampshire; and Cassidy travels to California to visit her older sister Courtney and explore the possibility of her family moving back to LA for good.
While the club members are split up, their moms have arranged a Secret Santa gift exchange, only thanks to Jess's mischievous little brothers, all the gifts are switched, leading to bad feelings all around.
The contrivances and misunderstandings around the Secret Santa gifts are a little much, as both Jess and Emma and Megan and Becca spend the holidays getting mad at one another over nothing. Jess and Emma in particular grate, as they've been BFFs for so long that their being torn apart by petty lies spread by strangers rather than actually talking to one another is fairly unbelievable. More annoying is Frederick's decision to make the dreamy cruise ship captain's son speak French, when she's not actually fluent in the language. Philippe makes his way through a crowd with Becca by saying "Let's excuse ourselves," rather than "Excuse us," as Frederick no doubt intended.
This installment in the series is notable in that it marks the first time Becca, Chadwickius frenemus, gets to narrate point-of-view chapters. It's also different in that it encompasses only half a school year -- and most of that is in a quick flashback; the actual narrative covers only Thanksgiving through New Year's, that is, the "holidays" of the title.
Speaking of the title, no one actually is "home" over the school holidays. The Chadwicks and the Wongs have booked a cruise together, a plan that gets fraught with complications when Becca's dad loses his job; Jess and Emma spend Christmas with Jess's aunt and uncle in New Hampshire; and Cassidy travels to California to visit her older sister Courtney and explore the possibility of her family moving back to LA for good.
While the club members are split up, their moms have arranged a Secret Santa gift exchange, only thanks to Jess's mischievous little brothers, all the gifts are switched, leading to bad feelings all around.
The contrivances and misunderstandings around the Secret Santa gifts are a little much, as both Jess and Emma and Megan and Becca spend the holidays getting mad at one another over nothing. Jess and Emma in particular grate, as they've been BFFs for so long that their being torn apart by petty lies spread by strangers rather than actually talking to one another is fairly unbelievable. More annoying is Frederick's decision to make the dreamy cruise ship captain's son speak French, when she's not actually fluent in the language. Philippe makes his way through a crowd with Becca by saying "Let's excuse ourselves," rather than "Excuse us," as Frederick no doubt intended.
Sunday, August 5, 2018
Book review: The Great Quake by Henry Fountain
The thirty-second book I read in 2018 was The Great Quake: How the Biggest Earthquake in North America Changed Our Understanding of the Planet by Henry Fountain. Like The Great Influenza, this book tells a story that ought to be compelling but in the end ... isn't.
Fountain does try. The book opens with geologists flying in to Anchorage two days after the disaster to examine the damage and learn what they can from the Good Friday 1964 quake. From there, Fountain jumps back in time to describe the towns and residents that were to be irrevocably changed in the quake. He alternates these chapters with background about his main character, a geologist named George Plafker who was his main source of information. It's not until about halfway through the book that the quake hits; the remainder of the pages deals with the casualties and survivors and the lessons scientists drew from the quake.
Unfortunately, few of the stories of those who lived or died are detailed enough to draw the reader into their tragedies. In large part, undoubtedly, this is due to the sheer passage of time between the event and the writing of the book; not enough of the bereaved could be contacted to tell their own or their lost loved ones' stories. Also, due to the sheer destruction, many of those who lived through the quake left the immediate area afterward and started over elsewhere, making them harder to track down. In addition, there is a language and cultural barrier with the Native Americans whose villages were some of the hardest hit which might have dissuaded them from sharing their experiences.
Whatever the reason, the dead are hard to empathize with. Due to the small number of families of one of the villages destroyed by the quake, many of them had similar or identical names, which makes it hard to keep track of who survives and who is lost. Also, Fountain is limited by who he has been able to interview all these years later. One of the most haunted deaths is that of a woman in Anchorage whose car is crushed by a stone facade which fell off of a department store; Fountain relates the story of a woman who witnessed this death, but the identity of the woman who died, what she was doing before the quake, and who mourned her after her passing remain untold.
As indicated by the long subtitle, a major focus of this book is on the confirmation of the theory of plate tectonics which resulted from the study of the Good Friday quake. It's interesting that plate tectonics was vehemently rejected by reputable scientists after Alfred Wegener proposed it, in large part merely because he was a meteorologist and geologists bristled at the concept of anyone but themselves coming up with such a breakthrough. Like the initial vitriol directed at Hoyle's Big Bang theory, it puts the lie to the fiction that science, at least as personified by scientists, is objective and disinterested.
Fountain does try. The book opens with geologists flying in to Anchorage two days after the disaster to examine the damage and learn what they can from the Good Friday 1964 quake. From there, Fountain jumps back in time to describe the towns and residents that were to be irrevocably changed in the quake. He alternates these chapters with background about his main character, a geologist named George Plafker who was his main source of information. It's not until about halfway through the book that the quake hits; the remainder of the pages deals with the casualties and survivors and the lessons scientists drew from the quake.
Unfortunately, few of the stories of those who lived or died are detailed enough to draw the reader into their tragedies. In large part, undoubtedly, this is due to the sheer passage of time between the event and the writing of the book; not enough of the bereaved could be contacted to tell their own or their lost loved ones' stories. Also, due to the sheer destruction, many of those who lived through the quake left the immediate area afterward and started over elsewhere, making them harder to track down. In addition, there is a language and cultural barrier with the Native Americans whose villages were some of the hardest hit which might have dissuaded them from sharing their experiences.
Whatever the reason, the dead are hard to empathize with. Due to the small number of families of one of the villages destroyed by the quake, many of them had similar or identical names, which makes it hard to keep track of who survives and who is lost. Also, Fountain is limited by who he has been able to interview all these years later. One of the most haunted deaths is that of a woman in Anchorage whose car is crushed by a stone facade which fell off of a department store; Fountain relates the story of a woman who witnessed this death, but the identity of the woman who died, what she was doing before the quake, and who mourned her after her passing remain untold.
As indicated by the long subtitle, a major focus of this book is on the confirmation of the theory of plate tectonics which resulted from the study of the Good Friday quake. It's interesting that plate tectonics was vehemently rejected by reputable scientists after Alfred Wegener proposed it, in large part merely because he was a meteorologist and geologists bristled at the concept of anyone but themselves coming up with such a breakthrough. Like the initial vitriol directed at Hoyle's Big Bang theory, it puts the lie to the fiction that science, at least as personified by scientists, is objective and disinterested.
Friday, July 27, 2018
Book review: As You Wish by Cary Elwes
The thirty-first book I read in 2018 was As You Wish: Inconceivable Tales from the Making of The Princess Bride by Cary Elwes with Joe Layden. Drop the "Inconceivable" (or, perhaps, use it as Vizzini did), and it's pretty much what it says on the tin: a behind-the-scenes from the movie, at least as remembered by the participants nearly three decades later.
On top of being one of the most delightful, most well-written, most well-cast, most well-directed movies ever made, "The Princess Bride" is also notable for preserving in amber, at the absolute height of their attractiveness, two of the most ludicrously good-looking people in the history of the world, Elwes and Robin Wright (later Robin Wright Penn, later just Robin Wright again). Frankly, were I one of them, I'm not sure I could harbor unadulterated good feelings toward the film, in that it endures as a living testament to the truth that neither one of them is as good-looking as they used to be, but I guess that's an occupational hazard of being a film actor.
I already knew some of the "inconceivable" tales, but not by any means all. For example, that Mandy Patinkin and Elwes tried to one-up one another in fencing practice rather like Doug and Kate battling to get on the ice first in "The Cutting Edge." That Westley was originally supposed to jump into the lightning sand feet-first to save Buttercup but Elwes didn't feel like it looked cool enough so he come up with the much-more-dangerous head-first dive. That Wallace Shawn is scared of heights and was terrified during the Cliff of Insanity scene. That most of Billy Crystal's and Carol Kane's dialogue was improvised. That Elwes broke his toe before shooting the final scene with Buttercup in his Dread Pirate Roberts guise and was both in great pain and desperately trying to conceal it from Rob Reiner in the fear he'd be fired and the part recast. That Christopher Guest actually did knock Elwes out hitting him with the butt of his sword.
Sadly, the lackluster release of the film led all involved to fear that their labor of love had been in vain. It was the video release that led to the widespread popularity of "The Princess Bride," and if VHS did nothing else for the world, that is enough.
On top of being one of the most delightful, most well-written, most well-cast, most well-directed movies ever made, "The Princess Bride" is also notable for preserving in amber, at the absolute height of their attractiveness, two of the most ludicrously good-looking people in the history of the world, Elwes and Robin Wright (later Robin Wright Penn, later just Robin Wright again). Frankly, were I one of them, I'm not sure I could harbor unadulterated good feelings toward the film, in that it endures as a living testament to the truth that neither one of them is as good-looking as they used to be, but I guess that's an occupational hazard of being a film actor.
I already knew some of the "inconceivable" tales, but not by any means all. For example, that Mandy Patinkin and Elwes tried to one-up one another in fencing practice rather like Doug and Kate battling to get on the ice first in "The Cutting Edge." That Westley was originally supposed to jump into the lightning sand feet-first to save Buttercup but Elwes didn't feel like it looked cool enough so he come up with the much-more-dangerous head-first dive. That Wallace Shawn is scared of heights and was terrified during the Cliff of Insanity scene. That most of Billy Crystal's and Carol Kane's dialogue was improvised. That Elwes broke his toe before shooting the final scene with Buttercup in his Dread Pirate Roberts guise and was both in great pain and desperately trying to conceal it from Rob Reiner in the fear he'd be fired and the part recast. That Christopher Guest actually did knock Elwes out hitting him with the butt of his sword.
Sadly, the lackluster release of the film led all involved to fear that their labor of love had been in vain. It was the video release that led to the widespread popularity of "The Princess Bride," and if VHS did nothing else for the world, that is enough.
Thursday, July 12, 2018
Book review: Heaven to Betsy and Betsy in Spite of Herself by Maud Hart Lovelace
The twenty-eighth book I read in 2018 was really two books, an omnibus edition of the fifth and sixth books in Maud Hart Lovelace's Betsy series, Heaven to Betsy and Betsy in Spite of Herself. As a child, I was never a fan of Lovelace; I recall trying to read Betsy-Tacy and quitting, unutterably bored. Betsy never found a magic wishing coin or traveled through a wardrobe into another world or met a witch or even, like Laura Ingalls Wilder, took a covered wagon out west and dealt with Indians and blizzards and wildfires. She was just a little girl going about everyday life in a small town, and I couldn't have cared less.
The next book in the Mother-Daughter Book Club series, however, is based on the Betsy series, particularly these last books dealing with her high school years and past, so I thought I'd give Betsy another try and see if she got any more interesting as a teenager.
More interesting, yes, but likable, not particularly. In what is now a trope (hello, Harry Potter), each of the next four books in the series deals with one school year in Betsy's life. In the first book, Betsy is getting ready to start high school as a freshman. The family moves away from her childhood home across the street from Tacy's house on the Big Hill and into a larger, more modern house nearer the center of town. Between her older sister Julia and Betsy, they make the Ray house a frequent destination for school friends, both boys and girls. In the second book, Betsy is a sophomore and travels to Milwaukee over Christmas to visit Tib, who moved away since the childhood books.
There's not a great deal more action than in the books chronicling Betsy's childhood years; instead, the narrative focuses on Betsy's ambitions for popularity. Tacy is firmly sidelined in favor of more typical high school girl friends, not only by Betsy, but also by the author: although Betsy seems to "learn her lesson" a time or two over the course of the stories and spends time with Tacy, Lovelace glosses over that time off-screen, clearly preferring to depict the popular girls. While morally questionable, it is this very choice that makes the books interesting today, in their portrayal of a very different style of adolescence: shirtwaists, pompadours over rats, putting on powder with a chamois skin (acceptable for decent girls) and putting on rouge with a rabbit's foot (the behavior of actresses and loose women), dance cards, a school teacher openly courting a senior girl, etc.
While I have decried Sweet-Valleyism in the Mother-Daughter Book Club, these books serve as prototypes. Each can't resist an early description of Betsy's slim waist and peaches-and-cream complexion, in prose little different than each installment of Sweet Valley High's description of the physical perfection of the Wakefield Twins, right down to Jessica/Betsy twirling around in front of a mirror and complaining about her physical flaws.
Betsy is decidedly boy-crazy, not in the sense of falling for any particular boy but more longing for the power which she discerns in her older sister Julia of being able to lead one around on a string and then drop him for a new model when she gets bored. Her obsession with popularity leads to her failure, in each book, to achieve the academic goals she has set for herself. One presumes that this will culminate, in her senior year, with academic triumph.
The next book in the Mother-Daughter Book Club series, however, is based on the Betsy series, particularly these last books dealing with her high school years and past, so I thought I'd give Betsy another try and see if she got any more interesting as a teenager.
More interesting, yes, but likable, not particularly. In what is now a trope (hello, Harry Potter), each of the next four books in the series deals with one school year in Betsy's life. In the first book, Betsy is getting ready to start high school as a freshman. The family moves away from her childhood home across the street from Tacy's house on the Big Hill and into a larger, more modern house nearer the center of town. Between her older sister Julia and Betsy, they make the Ray house a frequent destination for school friends, both boys and girls. In the second book, Betsy is a sophomore and travels to Milwaukee over Christmas to visit Tib, who moved away since the childhood books.
There's not a great deal more action than in the books chronicling Betsy's childhood years; instead, the narrative focuses on Betsy's ambitions for popularity. Tacy is firmly sidelined in favor of more typical high school girl friends, not only by Betsy, but also by the author: although Betsy seems to "learn her lesson" a time or two over the course of the stories and spends time with Tacy, Lovelace glosses over that time off-screen, clearly preferring to depict the popular girls. While morally questionable, it is this very choice that makes the books interesting today, in their portrayal of a very different style of adolescence: shirtwaists, pompadours over rats, putting on powder with a chamois skin (acceptable for decent girls) and putting on rouge with a rabbit's foot (the behavior of actresses and loose women), dance cards, a school teacher openly courting a senior girl, etc.
While I have decried Sweet-Valleyism in the Mother-Daughter Book Club, these books serve as prototypes. Each can't resist an early description of Betsy's slim waist and peaches-and-cream complexion, in prose little different than each installment of Sweet Valley High's description of the physical perfection of the Wakefield Twins, right down to Jessica/Betsy twirling around in front of a mirror and complaining about her physical flaws.
Betsy is decidedly boy-crazy, not in the sense of falling for any particular boy but more longing for the power which she discerns in her older sister Julia of being able to lead one around on a string and then drop him for a new model when she gets bored. Her obsession with popularity leads to her failure, in each book, to achieve the academic goals she has set for herself. One presumes that this will culminate, in her senior year, with academic triumph.
Monday, July 9, 2018
Book review: The House of Unexpected Sisters by Alexander McCall Smith
The twenty-seventh book I read in 2018 was the eighteenth installment in Alexander McCall Smith's No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency series, The House of Unexpected Sisters. There's actually no paying job in this book, as Precious and Grace take on a charity case (literally!) and turn down a client at the end of the book because they don't agree with her motivations. Perhaps McCall Smith is getting Mma Ramotswe confused with his other protagonist, Isabel Dalhousie, for whom money is no object.
The pro bono case the agency takes on is that of Charity (get it?) Mompoloki, a widow with young children who lost her job at an office furniture store for what she insists are unfair reasons, but the real meat of the story deals with Precious Ramotswe's discovery of a secret which casts a shadow over her memory of the daddy, the late sainted Obed Ramotswe.
The pro bono case the agency takes on is that of Charity (get it?) Mompoloki, a widow with young children who lost her job at an office furniture store for what she insists are unfair reasons, but the real meat of the story deals with Precious Ramotswe's discovery of a secret which casts a shadow over her memory of the daddy, the late sainted Obed Ramotswe.
Sunday, July 8, 2018
Book review: Pies and Prejudice by Heather Vogel Frederick
The twenty-sixth book I read in 2018 was the fourth book in Heather Vogel Frederick's Mother-Daughter Book Club series, Pies and Prejudice. The girls are entering ninth grade, and their book for the year (clearly) is Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice.
But the girls aren't all entering ninth grade together. Jess already abandoned the public school last year when she moved into a boarding school dorm, despite living in the same town the school is in; this year, Emma and her family are spending the school year in Bath since her father sold the novel he'd been working on. Technology to the rescue, as Mr. Wong hooks up videoconferencing equipment for book club meetings.
The Hawthornes work a house swap with a British family with two sons, one of whom is handsome and charming while the other is distant and arrogant ... and I'm sure you can see where this is going. There's a lot of boyfriend stuff this time around, as Megan falls forBingley, uh, Simon, Becca goes to the Spring Formal with Zach Norton, Jess and Darcy finally get together, Stewart breaks up with Emma, and the author rips off pays homage to The Cutting Edge with Cassidy and the Darcy-stand-in, Tristan.
Frederick sprinkles the background with Austen Easter eggs, like the choir director Mr. Elton, the teacher Ms. Bates, and Emma's Knightley-Martin School. The rather ham-handed title is derived from a baking business the club begins to pay for an airline ticket for Emma to fly home for spring break (which, coincidentally, is the same week as spring break at Alcott High and Colonial Academy), which in turn follows a sudden and convenient passion to learn cake decorating on the part of Jess and her mom. It's pretty out of left field.
The Sweet-Valleyism is a given with this series by now, but my main concern was mean-spirited actions of the girls seemingly being condoned by the author. Megan finds her niche in high school by publishing an anonymous "What Not to Wear" blog, trashing the fashion choices of her schoolmates. She is eventually found out, and her mom forces her to apologize; but she receives considerable positive affirmation for her exploits from a magazine publisher who implicitly tells her to wait until she's 18 and then she can make fun of others with impunity for a paycheck.
Emma's father's novel (besides being awful -- Frederick really shouldn't have posted a supposed excerpt) contains thinly-disguised caricatures of people he knows, prompting a feud with Mrs. Chadwick, whose doppelganger is particularly unattractive. (And I've read reviews of the series who point out that continually mocking a character for the size of her posterior is hardly a feminist undertaking.)
And Emma herself has a story published in the Knightley-Martin school literary magazine mocking a group of girls at the school before flying back to the US consequence-free -- a public shaming for which her father and one of the girls' relatives congratulates her. Emma (with Frederick) excuses herself with the assurance that no one but the girls being made fun of will know it's them and they deserve it, but given that the bad fairies in the story have the exact same nicknames as the four girls in real life, it's a ridiculous conclusion.
For a series that has gone out of its way to redeem Becca Chadwick and Savannah Sinclair, it's petty to dump on Annabelle Fairfax and her satellites. And for a series based on celebrating female characters, to condone mockery of (other) female characters for their weight and fashion choices is backwards.
But the girls aren't all entering ninth grade together. Jess already abandoned the public school last year when she moved into a boarding school dorm, despite living in the same town the school is in; this year, Emma and her family are spending the school year in Bath since her father sold the novel he'd been working on. Technology to the rescue, as Mr. Wong hooks up videoconferencing equipment for book club meetings.
The Hawthornes work a house swap with a British family with two sons, one of whom is handsome and charming while the other is distant and arrogant ... and I'm sure you can see where this is going. There's a lot of boyfriend stuff this time around, as Megan falls for
Frederick sprinkles the background with Austen Easter eggs, like the choir director Mr. Elton, the teacher Ms. Bates, and Emma's Knightley-Martin School. The rather ham-handed title is derived from a baking business the club begins to pay for an airline ticket for Emma to fly home for spring break (which, coincidentally, is the same week as spring break at Alcott High and Colonial Academy), which in turn follows a sudden and convenient passion to learn cake decorating on the part of Jess and her mom. It's pretty out of left field.
The Sweet-Valleyism is a given with this series by now, but my main concern was mean-spirited actions of the girls seemingly being condoned by the author. Megan finds her niche in high school by publishing an anonymous "What Not to Wear" blog, trashing the fashion choices of her schoolmates. She is eventually found out, and her mom forces her to apologize; but she receives considerable positive affirmation for her exploits from a magazine publisher who implicitly tells her to wait until she's 18 and then she can make fun of others with impunity for a paycheck.
Emma's father's novel (besides being awful -- Frederick really shouldn't have posted a supposed excerpt) contains thinly-disguised caricatures of people he knows, prompting a feud with Mrs. Chadwick, whose doppelganger is particularly unattractive. (And I've read reviews of the series who point out that continually mocking a character for the size of her posterior is hardly a feminist undertaking.)
And Emma herself has a story published in the Knightley-Martin school literary magazine mocking a group of girls at the school before flying back to the US consequence-free -- a public shaming for which her father and one of the girls' relatives congratulates her. Emma (with Frederick) excuses herself with the assurance that no one but the girls being made fun of will know it's them and they deserve it, but given that the bad fairies in the story have the exact same nicknames as the four girls in real life, it's a ridiculous conclusion.
For a series that has gone out of its way to redeem Becca Chadwick and Savannah Sinclair, it's petty to dump on Annabelle Fairfax and her satellites. And for a series based on celebrating female characters, to condone mockery of (other) female characters for their weight and fashion choices is backwards.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Blog Archive
Labels
- Agatha Christie (3)
- Alexander McCall Smith (23)
- apologia pro sua vita (49)
- Art Linkletter (29)
- Austeniana (10)
- bibliography (248)
- birthday (21)
- Charles Lenox (3)
- Christmas (29)
- deep thoughts by Jack Handy (16)
- Grantchester Mysteries (4)
- Halloween (10)
- high horse (55)
- Holly Homemaker (19)
- Hornblower (3)
- Inspector Alan Grant (6)
- Isabel Dalhousie (8)
- life-changing magic! (5)
- Lord Peter Wimsey (6)
- Maisie Dobbs (9)
- Mark Forsyth (2)
- Mother-Daughter Book Club (9)
- No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency (14)
- photo opportunity (103)
- pop goes the culture (73)
- rampant silliness (17)
- refrigerator door (11)
- Rosemary Sutcliff (9)
- something borrowed (73)
- the grandeur that was (11)
- where the time goes (70)






